A teacher and a student standing in a school library having a calm conversation, the teacher listening thoughtfully

Navigating Difficult Conversations in Schools

November 10, 2026•9 min read

Navigating Difficult Conversations in Schools: What Makes the Difference?

There's a moment most school leaders and educators will recognise.

A parent arrives at your office, clearly upset about something that happened to their child. A colleague becomes defensive when you raise a concern. A student shuts down halfway through a conversation, or responds with anger when you ask what happened.

You know the conversation matters. You know something needs to be addressed. But the words you choose next could either open the conversation up or make an already difficult situation considerably harder.

Difficult conversations are part of working in schools. We can't avoid them, nor should we. They are often the moments when relationships, trust and our capacity to work through challenges are really tested.

And yet, most of us have experienced conversations where, despite our best intentions, things haven't gone particularly well.

So what makes the difference?

When Emotions Take Over

One of the things worth understanding about difficult conversations is that they are not simply communication challenges. They are also nervous system events. When someone feels threatened, criticised, embarrassed, unheard or powerless, their nervous system can shift into a protective state. They may become defensive, angry, withdrawn or less willing to engage.

In schools, this can sound like:

  • "You never support my child."

  • "I'm sick of dealing with this student."

  • "No one listens to me."

  • "This is completely unfair."

  • "I'm done having this conversation."

It's tempting to respond to the words themselves, particularly when they feel unreasonable or personally directed at us. We might correct the facts, defend our position or insist that the other person calm down. The problem is that someone who feels threatened or overwhelmed is often less able to listen, reflect or consider another perspective. This is where understanding regulation becomes so important.

When emotions are running high, our capacity for reasoning, perspective-taking and problem-solving can become compromised. The more emotionally activated we become, the harder it can be to access the thinking skills needed to navigate the very conversation we're trying to have. This applies to the person we're speaking with. And it applies to us.

Regulation Before Resolution

Imagine a parent who is raising their voice because they believe their child has been treated unfairly.

One response might be:

"You need to calm down."

Another might be:

"I can see this has been really frustrating for you. I'd like to understand what's happened. Let's slow things down so we can work through it."

Both responses recognise that the conversation is becoming difficult. But they are likely to create very different conditions for what happens next. The second response acknowledges the parent's emotional experience without necessarily agreeing with their interpretation of events. It also offers a way forward.

This is an important distinction. Validation is not agreement. We can acknowledge someone's frustration without accepting their version of events, excusing harmful behaviour or abandoning our own expectations. And regulation doesn't mean we have to tolerate aggression or continue a conversation that has become unsafe. Sometimes the most relational response is to establish a clear boundary and agree to return to the discussion when everyone is better able to participate.

The aim is not to avoid the difficult issue. It's to create the conditions in which the issue can actually be addressed.

Get Curious, Not Furious

One of the most useful shifts we can make during difficult conversations is moving from judgement to curiosity. When we're feeling challenged, it's easy to make assumptions about the other person's intentions.

They're being difficult.

They're deliberately disrespecting me.

They just want to argue.

These interpretations can quickly shape our response, often before we've had an opportunity to understand what's really happening.

But what if the parent's anger is connected to fear for their child? What if the staff member's defensiveness reflects a feeling of inadequacy or being unsupported? What if the student's refusal to engage is actually a response to embarrassment or overwhelm?

We don't know until we become curious.

At Restorative Pathways, we often use the phrase "Get curious, not furious." It's a simple reminder that the story we're telling ourselves about another person's behaviour may not be the whole story.

Consider a student who storms out of class after receiving feedback. We could interpret the behaviour as defiance and respond accordingly. Or we could recognise that something about the interaction may have felt overwhelming and seek to understand what happened.

"I noticed you left pretty quickly after we spoke. I'm wondering what was happening for you at that point?"

The behaviour still needs to be addressed. The impact on others may still need to be explored. But curiosity gives us information that judgement alone cannot. And that information is often what helps us respond more effectively.

Five Things Worth Practising

Knowing that we should remain calm and curious is one thing. Actually doing it when someone is upset, challenging our decisions or questioning our competence is another. These are skills that need practice, particularly when the conversation matters to us personally.

Here are five approaches worth developing.

1. Start with yourself

Before trying to regulate someone else, pay attention to what's happening for you.

Notice your breathing, your tone of voice, your body language and the pace at which you're speaking. Are you becoming defensive? Are you rushing to explain yourself? Are you listening to understand or simply waiting for your turn to respond? Sometimes a slower breath, a quieter voice or a few seconds of silence is enough to interrupt a reactive response.

Our presence communicates as much as our words. A calm, grounded adult can help create a sense of safety, while an increasingly reactive adult can unintentionally add to the emotional intensity. This doesn't mean we won't feel frustrated or upset. It means learning to recognise those feelings without allowing them to determine what happens next.

2. Lead with warm curiosity

One of my favourite phrases in difficult conversations is:

"Help me understand."

It's simple, but it communicates something important. I'm interested in your perspective, and I recognise that I may not have the whole picture.

Compare these two questions:

"Why would you do that?"

"Help me understand what was happening for you at that point."

The first can sound like an accusation, even when that's not our intention. The second creates an opportunity for explanation and reflection.

Warm curiosity is not about being passive or avoiding difficult truths. It's about approaching the conversation with an openness to learning something we don't yet know. We can be curious and still be clear about expectations. We can listen with compassion and still address harm.

3. Describe what you've noticed, not what you've assumed

When we're frustrated, it's easy to move from describing someone's behaviour to making judgements about their character or intentions.

"You were disrespectful."

"You're being aggressive."

"You clearly don't care about the team."

The problem with these statements is that they invite people to defend themselves against the label, rather than reflect on what actually happened. An observation gives us a more useful starting point.

"I noticed that voices became raised during the meeting, and we weren't able to finish the discussion."

Or:

"I've noticed the planning documents haven't been uploaded by the agreed time for the past few weeks."

These statements are specific, factual and open to discussion. They also allow us to address behaviour and its impact without reducing the person to the behaviour.

4. Acknowledge emotion without losing clarity

People are more likely to engage constructively when they feel heard. That doesn't mean we need to agree with everything they say. Sometimes a simple acknowledgement can change the direction of a conversation.

"I can understand why that would feel frustrating."

"It sounds like this has been weighing on you."

"I can hear how important this is to you."

Validation helps communicate that someone's experience matters. It can reduce the pressure they feel to keep explaining, defending or escalating their position in order to be heard. But it's equally important to maintain clarity.

"I can hear how upset you are, and I want to understand what's happened. We do need to speak respectfully to one another if we're going to work through this."

Compassion and boundaries are not competing ideas. In restorative practice, we need both.

5. Keep the focus on understanding, impact and what happens next

Difficult conversations can easily become stuck in competing versions of events. One person explains what happened. The other disagrees. Both become increasingly invested in defending their position.

Restorative questions can help move the conversation beyond blame and towards understanding and responsibility.

"What was happening for you at the time?"

"What was the hardest part of that situation?"

"Who else has been affected, and how?"

"What do you think needs to happen now?"

These questions invite people to consider their own experience alongside the experiences of others.

Importantly, we don't need to ask every question in every conversation. Nor should we treat them as a script to work through regardless of the person's emotional state. Sometimes the most useful thing we can do is listen. Sometimes we need to clarify an expectation. Sometimes the conversation needs to happen later.

The skill lies in recognising what is needed in that moment.

Difficult Conversations Are Relationship Work

In busy schools, there is understandable pressure to resolve problems quickly.

We have classes to teach, meetings to attend, parents to respond to and an endless list of competing demands. It's tempting to measure a successful conversation by whether the issue has been dealt with and everyone can move on.

But a conversation can be finished without being resolved. And an issue can be addressed without the relationship being strengthened. This is particularly important when we think about the experiences of staff.

We often ask educators to respond to students with patience, curiosity, compassion and a commitment to maintaining relationships. But are we creating the same conditions for adults? When a staff member makes a mistake, feels overwhelmed or disagrees with a decision, do they experience the same relational approach we're asking them to provide for students?

The way leaders navigate difficult conversations contributes to the culture of a school. It communicates what happens when people disagree, when mistakes are made and when expectations aren't met. If we want young people to develop the capacity to navigate conflict constructively, they need to see the adults around them doing the same. And if we want staff to lead with curiosity and compassion, they need opportunities to experience, practise and develop those skills themselves.

A Question Worth Considering

Think about the last difficult conversation you had at school. Perhaps it went well. Perhaps you walked away wishing you'd handled something differently. Rather than focusing only on what was said, consider what was happening in the moment. Did both people feel heard? Was there enough emotional safety for an honest exchange? Were expectations clear? Was there an opportunity to understand the impact and identify a way forward?

We won't always get these conversations right. Sometimes we'll become reactive, make assumptions or say something we later regret. That's part of being human, too. What matters is our willingness to reflect, take responsibility and repair when necessary.

Because difficult conversations aren't interruptions to the relational work of schools.

They are some of the most important opportunities we have to put that work into practice.

Kristy Elliott

Kristy Elliott

Kristy Elliott is an experienced educator, consultant, and the founder of Restorative Pathways. With a background in teaching and a Master of Applied Positive Psychology from the University of Melbourne, Kristy brings more than two decades of experience supporting schools to build relational, restorative cultures. Passionate about wellbeing, inclusion, and growth, Kristy partners with educators to create safe, connected, and thriving communities through evidence-informed restorative practices. Her work is grounded in compassion, backed by research, and delivered with warmth.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Back to Blog